The Consultant Conundrum: When CIS Framework Fanatics Become the Biggest Cybersecurity Risk

In the world of cybersecurity, the CIS (Center for Internet Security) Controls framework is heralded as the gold standard. And for good reason—it provides a comprehensive, structured approach to securing an organization's digital environment. But when followed blindly, it can become a crutch for so-called "experts" who lack the creativity or courage to think critically. Enter the consultants, the self-proclaimed saviors of cybersecurity, who cling to these frameworks as if they’re gospel, leaving companies vulnerable not to hackers, but to the ineptitude of their own paid advisors.

Take, for instance, a hypothetical scenario where a critical cybersecurity measure is downplayed or removed from a framework update. A consultant blindly following the framework might argue that the missing step is no longer important, even though it could represent a glaring vulnerability for the business. Instead of tailoring their advice to real-world risks and using logic to address obvious threats, consultants often hide behind the framework, absolving themselves of accountability. After all, they’re just “following best practices,” right?

And therein lies the rub. Consultants take no risk. If their advice fails, they still get paid—usually to fix their own mess. If a breach occurs, they blame the client for “improper implementation” while drafting another invoice. Meanwhile, the business is left picking up the pieces, financially and reputationally, as consultants smugly pat themselves on the back for their "adherence to standards."

At Digital Bunker 365, we call this what it is: professional malpractice. Cybersecurity isn’t about blindly following a checklist; it’s about protecting businesses in a practical, common-sense way. That’s why we start with a thorough assessment of each client’s unique environment, tailoring controls and security measures to meet day-to-day requirements. We don’t just regurgitate CIS Controls or any other framework—we use them as tools, not commandments.

Our approach prioritizes pragmatism and outcomes. Instead of wasting resources on irrelevant or outdated recommendations, we focus on maximizing your existing investments—especially in the Microsoft platform. From security to monitoring to management, we ensure that your technology empowers your business, not hinders it. And unlike consultants, we don’t hide behind excuses or frameworks. Our clients don’t pay for us to fix the same problem twice.

It’s time for businesses to rethink their reliance on consultants who bring little more than PowerPoint presentations and templated advice to the table. Yes, cybersecurity frameworks like CIS have value, but only when applied with critical thought and a deep understanding of the specific challenges a business faces. If your consultant can’t see past the framework, then they’re not mitigating risks—they are the risk.

So the next time a consultant suggests you blindly follow a framework, ask them this: “What risk are you taking?” When the answer is “none,” maybe it’s time to find a partner who will.

Related posts